MS Region I, Grades 1-6

Score each of the criteria as noted below for a total of 100 possible points.

                                Problem Statement [ ___ out of 15]
___ Does the problem show creative ability and originality in the questions asked? (5)
___ Has the problem been clearly defined? (5)
___ Are the variables clearly recognized and defined? (5)
                                                            Or
                                  Engineering Goal [ ___ out of 15]
___ Does the project have a clear objective, and is it relevant to the potential user? (5)
___ Is the solution workable, acceptable to the potential user, and economically feasible? (5)
___ Is the solution a significant improvement over previous alternatives? (5)

                                  Literature Review [ ___ out of 10]
___ Does the project include a comprehensive review of the literature, using at least 
       3-4 well-chosen primary sources? (4)
___ Does the project include an accurate synthesis of the literature? (1)
___ Is there an accurate use, and consistent style in citations and references? (1)
___ Does the project demonstrate an understanding of literature cited? (4)

                               Hypothesis and Method [ ___ out of 20] 
___ Is the hypothesis clearly communicated and tied to literature review? (10)
___ Are the methods of sampling and assignment appropriate and clearly 
       explained? (5) 
___ Are the instruments and procedures used appropriate, and has their reliability and 
       validity been discussed if necessary? (5)

                                           Results [ ___ out of 20]
___ Was the purpose carried out to completion within the scope of the original 
       intent? (5)
___ Were appropriate methods of data analysis employed? (5)
___ Were tables and/or figures used appropriately? (5)
___ Were reasonable conclusions drawn from the data? (5)

                                     Oral presentation [ ___ out of 20] 
___ Has the student communicated a clear understanding of the following:

       (Science) Question – Hypothesis – Procedure – Data – Conclusion(20)
                                                                                                     Or
       (Engineering) Problem – Objective – Relevancy – Feasibility – 
       Improvement from past solutions – Economic Feasibility – Testing (20)

                               Board Presentation [ ___ out of 10]
___ Does the project display board clearly communicate its intent? (10)

                                                            General [ ___ out of 5]
___ Are all appropriate forms available in a folder at project display? (5)